Definitely not smudge proof, it smudges under my eyes within an hour of wear. Wouldn’t buy it again.

I love how this mascara makes my eyelashes look, but sometimes it flakes in my eyes and the wand is very heavy. I have an essential tremor and especially when I am already fatigued it’s so hard to use because it makes my hand so shaky. Also the piece that squeegees the excess has come off in the lid and that was only my second use. I got it back on, but for the price it shouldn’t do that imo. So while it’s a great mascara, I probably won’t buy it again or recommend to anyone with a handicap similar to mine.

I purchased a Mitzi mascara from Chempro a couple of months ago, and within two months it became sticky and wax-like. It was very difficult to remove from my eyelashes and caused severe irritation in one eye. I am extremely disappointed to have paid such a high price for a product of this poor quality. I am left wondering whether this item was adequately tested before being released to the market.

After years of relying on lash extensions, I was hesitant to switch to mascara due to the dreaded panda eyes and the breakage I’d experienced. But Eco by Sonya’s Mitzi Mascara has completely changed the game for me! This mascara is next-level amazing—my lashes look noticeably longer and fuller without any smudging or flaking. Best of all, I feel like my lashes are actually getting healthier and growing stronger since I started using it. It’s clean, vegan, and gentle on my sensitive eyes, yet delivers bold, dramatic results. This is hands-down my new go-to mascara—an absolute must-try!

This is such a good mascara! Will be repurchasing for sure!